SB Nation - Login for mobile commenting

Bloody Elbow

UFC 142 RIO: Jose Aldo vs. Chad Mendes Dissection

Fighter images via UFC.com

Fighter images via UFC.com

The centerpiece of tonight's UFC 142 RIO: Aldo vs. Mendes pay-per-view is a featherweight fracas pitting divisional monarch and top pound-for-pound candidate Jose Aldo in his fifth title defense against unbeaten Team Alpha Male wrestler Chad Mendes.

Jose Aldo (20-1) has been methodically sniping off the top end of the 145-pound totem pole. His systematic elimination began at WEC 44 against American Top Team's rugged veteran Mike Brown, who, unbeknownst to him, was wearing Aldo's future around his waist. The Brazilian had earned his shot with five highlight-reel stoppages in the WEC but Brown's cachet and power-grappling was purported to be a rude awakening.

And it was, but crosswise: Aldo eschewed Brown's takedowns and surprisingly landed one of his own in the second, then teleported instantly to back-mount and pounded him out to become champion. He'd already proven that he was a human wood-chipper on the feet by mangling foes with a cyclone of Muay Thai, but beating someone of Brown's caliber at his own game foreshadowed the complex monster that Jose Aldo has become today.

Next up was former longstanding champ and poster-boy Urijah Faber. Aldo spent all five rounds sawing his leg in half with unending waves of wicked roundhouse kicks, causing even the at-home viewers to wince in sympathetic pain each time his shin plunged sickeningly deep into "The California Kid's" tenderized thigh. Then it was Hayastan bruiser Manny Gamburyan. Bam. Lights out. Second round. Mark it, dude.

The champ's last two defenses were sturdy decisions over Mark Hominick and Kenny Florian. Some feel they exposed some holes in Aldo's game; others opine that they merely dragged the champ into deeper waters and weren't crushed immediately like the rest. I side with the latter.


More UFC 142 Dissections

Belfort Vs. Johnson | Palhares Vs. Massenzio | Barboza Vs. Etim | Silva Vs. Prater | FX Prelims


Chad "Money" Mendes (11-0) has never lost a fight. In fact, he's never even been put in a precarious situation nor revealed any glaring weaknesses. The closest thing to a hole he might have is that he's mostly a one-dimensional wrestler, but that one dimension has delivered a perfect MMA record and expedited him to a title shot in just over three years of professional competition.

A former Division 1 wrestler at Cal-Poly, Mendes tore through his first five opponents (1 sub, 2 TKOs, 2 decisions) relying mostly on his voracious takedowns and startling athleticism. While rounding out his overall skill-set with Team Alpha Male, Mendes signed with the WEC and proceeded to skyrocket up the ladder. He handed Roufusport juggernaut Erik Koch his first loss (decision), submitted Anthony Morrison (guillotine choke), and then rattled off four decision victories to assume the role of apex-contender: Cub Swanson, Javier Vazquez, Michihiro Omigawa and Rani Yahya.

Three of those fighters are BJJ black belts, two of which are at the ceiling level (Yahya, Javi) and Omigawa is still a force to be reckoned with on the mat. Some fans frowned upon Mendes' control-based strategy, yet tossing around fighters of this prestige and fearlessly diving into the jaws of their guards was extremely impressive for someone as green as Mendes. All the while, his boxing was looking sharper in each outing and he was still as lightning-fast and explosive as ever.

Gifs and analysis in the full entry.

SBN coverage of UFC 142 RIO: Aldo vs. Mendes

Star-divide

I enjoy being overly dramatic in my writing and embellishing the analysis to portray the fighters like comic-book superheroes. I've put together a heaping assembly of gifs for Jose Aldo, but instead of saucing up each one with exhausting metaphors, I think the sheer violence herein speaks for itself. Just take a minute and soak each one of these in.

Jose-aldo-o_medium

24qqzw5_jpg_medium

Jose-aldo-o_medium

Jose-aldo-whoops-urijah-faber-o_medium


Aldoheadmovement00_medium

My professional assessment of the gifs above: that is some seriously frightening ass-kicking. This is MMA, so all the competitors are fighters. They fight for a living. Some are aggressive. Some are composed. Some are resplendently technical, others are brutally raw.

However, Jose Aldo is a f**king fighter, in every sense of the word. He can do it all and he's both fundamentally polished and uncontrollably destructive.

To the right is a subtle example of his artful skill, without even throwing a punch. When you think Mark Hominick, "technical kickboxing" should immediately come to mind. Aldo hangs out in the pocket and puts on a veritable clinic of how to slip punches.

Jose_aldo_vs

My point is that Aldo is stamped as a Thai wrecking machine, and rightfully so, but he doesn't get enough credit for the astronomical level of abilities he's shown in so many different areas.

Here the champ attacks with what many assume to be his weakness. Admittedly, Aldo has never encountered a wrestler like Mendes and he'll be hard-pressed to compete directly with a D1 standout, but there's no question that he's exhibited a very under-appreciated proficiency with both securing and defending takedowns.

8_medium

Florian made it clear that he intended to swallow him up in the clinch to stifle his offense, but the champ had none of it. Staying elusive with excellent circling, Aldo was adept in nabbing the whizzer and punishing the challenger with a medley of knees and dirty boxing. A salient factor is that, while his clinch tactics have passed the test, the only opponent to assail him with dropping levels and shooting from outside was Brown, and Mendes' freestyle wrestling is unparalleled in the division. Rather than contest Aldo upright in the clinch, Mendes will sink low with blindingly fast shots that are set up brilliantly with his strikes and footwork.

100000000000_medium

Mendes is truly an athletic specimen with obvious takedown prowess, but he implements his strengths very intelligently.

To the left, notice how he fakes a level drop to open things up. This causes Vazquez to freeze in place and brace for the takedown, and Mendes switches it up and cracks a high kick. In the ensuing blitzkrieg he follows with, the wrestler carefully measures his steps to shrink the distance and maintains excellent balance while pressuring with punches.

555555555555555555555555_medium

It's worth noting that, though he sets up the high kick and shows decent form with his aggressive boxing, his defensive mannerisms definitely offer some opportunities for a precise marksmen like Aldo.

Sure, the front roll and flip to the right might be a little more "show than go", but I applaud the high work-rate, activity and courage of Mendes. Vazquez is a complex submissionist and it takes huge cajones to pull off these theatrics. The way Mendes confronted such talented grapplers would indicate that Aldo will have a tough time sweeping or submitting from the bottom.

1_medium

All of my praise for Mendes' strides with his stand up comes with the disclaimer of how inexperienced he is. Plus, pure wrestlers typically struggle to get comfortable on their feet because of the opposing variables of stance and footwork, and Mendes has excelled phenomenally in putting it all together.

That being said, all of his offensive striking in these animations show a susceptibility to precise counter-punching, where Aldo reigns supreme. Despite his encouraging improvement, I can't help but think that Aldo is going to light him up on the feet.

2_medium

For everyone who equates Mendes with guys like Tyron Woodley who are "scared to fight" and "only play it safe", please review this collection of gifs and rethink your stance.

As far as physical attributes like strength, quickness, agility and conditioning, I'd put Mendes at the top of the heap. Aldo is still fleet afoot and will have a slight edge in height and reach, but the gist of the match up comes down to who can keep things in their preferred phase of combat.

Footwork will dictate the location of the fight and Mendes has incredible movement. While Aldo is a black belt in BJJ, Mendes has proven his prowess against others with the same accolades and Aldo didn't seem to scramble with busy hips and the sense of urgency I'd expect in his past performances. Mendes should be able to shut down his guard and be productive enough with ground and pound to avoid stand ups.

Aldo epitomizes the statement that "good offense is the best defense." The short, spearing knee he lands in the second gif might be a handy tool to keep Mendes wary about dropping levels. The champ has a wide arsenal of dangerous strikes to employ for an aspiring takedown artist, such as his uppercut and knees, which makes the area around his waist a very hostile environment to invade. If Mendes telegraphs his shots in the slightest, I can see him going to sleep. The contrasting variable is that Aldo will be at risk every time he plants his feet; it's something he must do to add velocity to his strikes. Footwork, distance and timing are factors of the utmost importance.

To summarize, it's just too hard to pick against an undefeated wrestler like Mendes, especially considering how much power takedowns and top control have in neutralizing other weapons and in the eyes of the judges. Mendes will likely be moving forward and pressing, which is generally received as more effective aggression. His chin has looked solid thus far but he's yet to encounter someone of Aldo's stature. I'd estimate their advantages to be about even in their respective specialties -- Mendes on the mat and Aldo standing -- but think Mendes has the better chance of implementing his cardinal weapon.

My Prediction: Chad Mendes by decision.

Aldo gif collection via Gifsoup.com

Aldo head-movement gif via ProMMANow.com

All others via Zombie Prophet of IronForgesIron.com

Poll
Jose Aldo vs. Chad Mendes
Jose Aldo
662 votes
Chad Mendes
275 votes

937 votes | Poll has closed

0 recs  |  53 comments

Comments

Aldo looked fired up at the weigh ins

I think he takes this in the 2nd.

he looked manic

And drawn and dry. I think his conditioning is going to suffer if this gets to the championship rounds

Nope

He looked loose and composed. I don’t see where you get that from.

Yeah, he looked happier than normal to me
I'm glad it was that

And not being pressured in front of a home town crowd.

Man, 20-1… someone better beat this kid soon or his record is going to start looking ridiculous.

That just shows how under-rated Azevedo is

Luciano has always been one of my favorite fighters outside of the limelight. Given, he got crushed in his big stateside opportunity against McKee, but he’d never competed under the Unified Rules with elbows, which takes some serious adjustment for a defending grappler.

What angers

me about that gif where Aldo is effortlessly slipping Hominick’s punches is hearing Rogan and Goldberg stay completely silent about it while praising Hominick for “outboxing” Aldo. I wish there gifs of some of the more “subtle” things Aldo does so great: his ability to pass guard (which he’s done to some fantastic grapplers no less), and his lateral movement.

Yeah Rogan and Goldie were awful in that fight, I remember being really angry about them Frank Mir-ing Hominick while completely ignoring Aldo’s head movement and how he was actually winning the fight

They've been off for a while now

And it sucks.

Anik is commentating for the prelims tonight right?

Yeah, IIRC they were even saying those punches were landing

They spent like 90% of the fight complaining that Aldo looked tired despite him dominating the fight.

What does IIRC mean?

I see it all the time

if I remember correctly
(FYI, it would have taken you a lot less time to google than post this question.)

what does FYI mean?
For your information

Not sure if serious though

If I Recall

I hear the opposite

Goldberg is very quick to praise Aldo’s head movement and ability to slip punches in several fights, but I wasn’t impressed at all against Hominick.

Sure, you can always find gifs that illustrate a moment of good head movement, but the stats show that he isn’t anywhere near the level of GSP or Silva. These are Hominick’s stats from striking distance to Aldo’s head:

6/49 power shots
32/76 jabs

Letting 42% of an opponent’s jabs hit you is not elite defense looks like. I’m not saying Hominick won, as Aldo clearly landed a fuckton more power shots, but Aldo isn’t one of those virtually untouchable guys like GSP, Silva, or Machida.

This is just me, but that's why I hate "stats" in MMA for striking

It’s extremely subjective and everyone cites them as if they are some sort of indisputable fact. It is nothing more than one knowledgeable perspective on the fight.

Things like TDs and TDD, sure, I’m all for it. Those are tangible and inarguable actions that either succeed or fail. But striking isn’t just a singular, hit-or-miss science. Punches can miss, glance ineffectively, glance and do surprising damage, land and be ineffective, land and be medium-effective, etc. Plus, when you’re dealing with 5 rounds (25 minutes) of high-production strikers, it’s impossible to accurately assess the impact of each blow.

The margin of error for striking stats is just enormous.

agreed

But I’d even say the TD and TDD stats can also give a false impression of a fight as well. If someone takes a fighter down for a second but they pop straight back up it would still count.

Totally agree

And that subjectivity is just for TDs and each strike comes along with a much broader “gray area” and there’s about ten times as many.

The cumulative effect is a massive margin for error and/or difference of opinion.

Uhh...

who are you talking to? Half your response is to a set of points I never even brought up.

Funny you mention GSP and Silva. Since, you know…Silva got outlanded by Sonnen in far greater numbers than Aldo has ever experienced, and GSP lost rounds according to some judges against Jake Shields and his jab of doom.

Although it wasn't a well formulated statement,

I have also found Aldo’s head movement to be overpraised. He’s certainly good and better than most in MMA, but I see him plant his feet then lose his balance too frequently when he starts to bob and weave. He also has a tendency to freeze up with his hands and not throw anything back. He’s still far from the levels of Anderson Silva. Compare the above Aldo-Hominick gif to this artistry of violence, where every slip is used to set up a strike or feint into a strike.

Kid still has a long ways and more western boxing training to go before he gets to that level.

Just to nitpick a little

The best striker in MMA history taking on Forrest Griffin is quite a skewed comparison to Aldo versus a high level technician like Hominick.

Plus, and I’m not denying it, but when has Aldo lost his balance frequently?

Let me clarify my choices of phrasing here.

I think Aldo’s head movement is overpraised because many people in the media and fan world have been saying he’s a mini-Anderson Silva. That is heaping an undue amount of praise on his defensive abilities. His ability to slip punches is quite good but far overpraised.

Also, my word choice was that he loses his balance “too frequently” not that he loses it frequently. I’d need to look back for specific examples but I remember in the Hominick fight and a few other moments when he would sway just too far and his center wouldn’t be over his feet anymore so he’d need to step out and regain his balance. It’s a huge window for a talented striker in the division (possibly Erik Koch?) to throw with power while Aldo has nothing to offer back.

And I apologize if this comes off with a confrontational tone, I’m just trying to clarify why I chose specific phrasing even though it didn’t quite communicate my message well. And I’m grumpy since I haven’t had coffee.

All good, wasn't received as "confrontational" in the slightest

And hopefully my response didn’t seem defensive. I get off on debating semantics like that so I was just interested in your reasoning.

While I think Anderson is paramount for all things striking, I can only recall a select few moments of Aldo wavering in balance against Hominick. Am I alone in believing that he was fairly gassed in the 4th and 5th of that fight? (i.e. “not an excuse” but an understandable deviation from the norm.)

I think he gassed there,

and I also think he was a bit gassed in the 5th against Urijah, hence why he coasted through it. Not a bad decision considering he’d just done bad, violent things in the 4th and Urijah was a dead man walking, but I’ve never forgotten that note.

If Mendes can put enough pressure on Aldo and get blood in his shoulders to slow down the punches then he’s saved himself from a lot of punishment up top. Then he needs to catch a few kicks for takedowns or use the Cheick Kongo Charlie Horse Elbows to make him hesitate or just slow down the kicks, footwork and knees. It’s doable and it sure won’t be easy but Mendes can slow him down while giving up the first two then take over 3-5. Maybe.

In their defense

Not only is it tough to see that stuff in “real-time”, but they’re also cage side and switching angles from the monitors and actual view.

I do appreciate your comment though because I always struggle with my coverage and detail for main events. There’s a full Judo Chop waiting for a lot of Aldo’s subtle brilliance but I still always like to do a mini-retrospect on their pathway leading up to the fight and overall skill set. Can be tough to find that balance.

I got Aldo winning, but this fight looks dead even on paper

It will probably be one of those fights which are one sided and you “shoulda saw it coming.”

I think if Mendes can’t beat Jose then no one at FW can.

I bet Frankie Edgar could beat him at FW.

While I would love Aldo winning, I think the smart money here is on Mendes putting a serious fitching on him. And not the Hendricks kind

Just as kind of a sidebar ramble

Going into a Dissection for close fights, I usually have a rough foundation of the variables and who I think will win. I typically only come to my conclusion after I’ve compiled everything and walk myself through the finite details.

I’d been leaning Mendes for a while but this exercise really makes me hesitant. It become much clearer how dominant Aldo should be standing and how much poise and finesse Mendes will have to apply his takedowns with.

Another random point of interest

I was intrigued by this stat-graph from Breakdown Fights.com but ended up not referencing it.

I think Jose Aldo is going to make this look easy

and then everyone is going to start feeling bad for Korean Zombie cause we all know hes going to get ko’d by Aldo.

Carbon copy

of the general consensus leading up to the Hominick fight.

Mendes has a MUCH better chance than Hominick IMO

My comment was referencing TKZ vs. Hominick/Aldo

Agreed on Mendes.

while it is true

I doubt we see Aldo rushing up to KZ and throwing wildly.

Aldo only does one thing to wrestlers

destroy them

Yeah, all 2 that he faced?

Plus the one he lost to? I guess you could throw in Brookins to make it 3, but I’d hardly say he’s proven against elite wrestlers and, as mentioned, none of them were purely freestyle nor of the caliber of Mendes.

Just sayin.

Mendes isn't purely freestyle

I don’t remember if he ever went to Fargo even

Mendes 8th at fargo in 2002 at 119 lbs

I think Dallas was lumping free and folk together, which is fine as both have the same applicable skillsets relevant to MMA.

Aldo has fought a wrestler of Mendes caliber (in terms of pedigree) at all, but for a questionable call, Chad would be a d1 national champ, the next best wrestler Aldo has fought, Faber, never was able to place at NCAAs

You are correct on the "lumping"

Am I mistaken to basically categorize H.S. and college wrestlers as either freestyle or Greco?

Yes

The scholastic/folk style wrestled by high schoolers and collegians is a different sport (different like Nascar and Indycar) than the Olympic styles of Greco/Free. Freestyle and American Folkstyle share many similarites, particularly when both wrestlers are on their feet. The differences between the two styles are the reason that our guys have fairly disappointing results at Olympic and World championships.

Hi everyone i have an IMPORTANT question

i keep hearing that there will be 2 prelim fights broadcasted on facebook but i cant find where. I would be thankful for any advice on this. I want to watch at least those two..

Go to Facebook,

and search for “UFC.” It’ll bring up their page, with a link to the fight stream. I’m sure there’s other ways, but that’s how I get there.

I just noticed

Me and you have identical records on Playground!

And tonight,

we’ll both be perfect. The trend continues!

Here's the link

http://www.facebook.com/UFC?sk=app_247211121995467

And last I heard only one fight was streaming on Facebook (Carvalho x Arantes).

You must Login with your SB Nation account and be a member of Bloody Elbow to post a comment.