SB Nation - Login for mobile commenting

Bloody Elbow

UFC On FX: Jim Miller vs. Melvin Guillard Dissection

Fighter images via UFC.com

Fighter images via UFC.com

Longtime upper-tier lightweights Jim Miller and Melvin Guillard will collide in the centerpiece of tonight's UFC on FX show from the Bridgestone Center in Nashville, Tennessee. The festivities begin with a six-piece preliminary lineup on Fuel TV at 6 p.m. ET to whet your appetite for the main course on the FX network at 9 p.m. ET.

So, we all know the score with Melvin Guillard (29-9-2) by now. With sheer athleticism and a natural inclination for all things fisticuffs, the New Orleans native devoured eighteen of his first twenty-four foes, finishing fourteen handily, with four losses, two draws and one No Contest. The arrestive sequence propelled "The Young Assassin", still in his early twenties, to a slot on the proven breeding grounds of The Ultimate Fighter in the reality show's second season.

Though he was out-muscled by savvy wrestler Josh Burkman and eliminated in the first match, his beaming confidence and wealth of untapped potential signified Guillard as a malleable future prospect. The cycle began: Guillard established his unruly striking with a second round TKO of Marcus Davis, but the promising win was darkened by the exploitation of his suspect grappling in the form of a Josh Neer triangle choke. He bounced back and rattled off two more dominant knockouts (Rick Davis, Gabe Ruediger) only to dampen his momentum with an equal number of submission losses (Joe Stevenson, Rich Clementi).

With a clear pattern developing, Guillard labored under the tutelage of Greg Jackson to hammer his takedown defense, BJJ awareness and scrambling skills into better shape, and immediately reaped the benefits. After picking up a decision win in what would be his last outing outside the UFC, Guillard vanquished German kickboxing champion Dennis Siver in the first and narrowly averted a precarious match up in a split-verdict decision over ATT black belt Gleison Tibau. Having won three straight and seemingly welded up his soft spots, Guillard was in the driver's seat against Nate Diaz until the spidery grappler constricted a fight-ending guillotine halfway through the second stanza. Next, it was five consecutive wins that rejuvenated his status (Ronys Torres, Waylon Lowe, Jeremy Stephens, Evan Dunham, Shane Roller) before he see-sawed downward again, only this time the pill was bitter to swallow as the ground-fighter (Joe Lauzon) initiated the submission with a crushing knockdown on the feet.


More UFC on FX Dissections

Ludwig vs. Neer | Easton vs. Papazian | Barry vs. Morecraft | Fuel TV Prelims


Perfectly emulating Guillard's Kryptonite is BJJ black belt and wrestle-boxer Jim Miller. While Guillard was also pining for a title shot, the AMA Fight Club gamer was widely considered the alpha-contender in the division. Debuting in the UFC with only one loss after his first twelve fights, Miller blue-collared his way into the hearts of fans and exuded an unflinching determination that belied his laid-back personality. He notched wins over David Baron and Matt Wiman before encountering Gray Maynard, the takedown machine that would eventually stalemate with Miller's only pre-UFC loss in Frankie Edgar while battling for the title of the world's numero uno lightweight.

The pair would engage in their electric trilogy atop the division while Miller buried himself in the trenches and clawed his way back up with seven straight victories (Mac Danzig, Steve Lopez, Duane Ludwig, Mark Bocek, Gleison Tibau, Charles Oliveira and Kamal Shalorus), winning nine of his ten UFC contests overall. Picking off a phone book full of reputable lightweights had Miller poised for a title shot, but when a draw and multiple injuries delayed the Maynard vs. Edgar resolution, Miller decided to stay busy and tackle WEC crossover Ben Henderson. The newcomer put on a showstopping performance and leap-frogged Miller on the totem pole in a commanding decision.

Both Guillard and Miller are fresh off a disheartening defeat and eager to regain momentum with a much needed win.

Gifs and analysis in the full entry.

SBN coverage of UFC on FX

Star-divide

1_medium_medium

This is the technically enhanced shtick Guillard rolls out to combat grappling threats.

Instead of going ballistic in a blaze of glory, Guillard has sharpened up his footwork to transfer his enormous punching power from a greater distance, which reduces his chances of being snared up and stifled. He's become much more calculating and selective with his boxing, making sure not to over-commit while offering nothing but the sting of leather for the opposing wrestler to work with. The formula was noticeably sweetened and emphasized by a more mature mentality.

2_medium_medium

Though he firmly governed his bloodlust, Guillard did not overcompensate and wisely maintained a stiff dose of the fiery aggression that elevated him in the first place. Despite still finding himself on the mat occasionally, his newly bolstered ground wit enabled him to sit up and butt-scoot toward the fence in his guard and use the cage to stand back up.

Dabbling in Judo at an early age endows Guillard with a strong base and excellent balance, so souping up his sprawl-and-brawl was an ideal shield for his flaws.

5_mediumMiller is a southpaw with stiff boxing, good wrestling and voracious submission grappling.

He's a no-frills fighter who never does anything fancy or excessive. Standing, the southpaw tosses in a high kick or two but generally assumes an airtight stance and targets the head with piston-like punches. He pushes the pace but does so with cerebral composure.

He rarely makes mistakes and excels at capitalizing on those of his opponent, as evinced against Charles Oliveira.

3_medium

Miller applied the brakes to the surging Brazilian by spinning for this brilliant kneebar from the top. Oliveira was conspicuously late to react and opted for the Charlie Horse attack instead, giving Miller all the time he needed to wrench the hold and elicit the tapout. Of the formidable three-dimensional threat that Miller wields, I'd rate his creative BJJ and adept boxing over his wrestling chops. He's not a weak wrestler by any means, but I wouldn't call him a dominant one either.

Along with Guillard's fortified takedown defense, he's a physically gifted athlete with considerable strength, explosive quickness and ultra-slippery scrambling. Conversely, Guillard has both fought and defeated better wrestlers than Miller, but none were as smart nor as crafty with submissions. I think Melvin might be able to fend him off better than some of his past foes, yet I expect Miller's exceptional fight IQ to flesh out more opportunities than the others -- and he's one of the best at maximizing on them.

The fact that Miller's never been knocked out or stopped in any magnitude justifies his slight gap on the betting lines. I'm genuinely torn on this match up: one could argue that Lauzon just caught the definitively improved Guillard and Miller can't replicate that same punching power, yet it's hard not to fall back on the more complete fighter whose specific strength is precisely where his opponent has a specific weakness.

My Prediction: Jim Miller by rear-naked choke.

All gifs via Zombie Prophet of IronForgesIron.com

Poll
Jim Miller vs. Melvin Guillard
Jim Miller
759 votes
Melvin Guillard
368 votes

1127 votes | Poll has closed

0 recs  |  99 comments

Comments

Melvin wins this in the first round.

All aboard!

yep agreed

i’d love to see miller win, i just dont think he does

I’ll be surprised if Guillard defeats Jim Miller.

Don't worry, Him got this. Gone run right thru Melvin
*Jim. I was thinking in Spanish
Let's make some sigbets happen here

I’m for Miller. Who’s game?

i would sig bet but i want miller
Same.

Tiddays and Machiel need to show some cojones up in here.

wanna sig bet on another fight?
how about ludwig vs neer, i get ludwig

How do these work again?

simple whoever wins chooses the other persons sig (i think, ive never done one before)

So we’ve got 3 for Miller? He’s the better overall fighter… but whatever I’ll take Guillard and represent psychoblack. Guillard gonna put a hurtin’ on Miller so bad he slaps himself on the way to the canvas. What’s the usual term for sig bets?

i have no friggin clue ive been trying to get one for a while now but im down for this big time
i guess simply winner chooses the sig of the loser for a month?

Works for me. Make it official? You’ve got Miller and I’ve got Guillard?

done and done my friend

It’s on. I guess we’ll settle up in one of the post-fight threads? Now I’ve got to come up with something humiliating and funny.

im gonna make a fanpost saturday night

im a religious Jew so i wont know any results till then so keep your eyes peeled

I don't get it.

Why not until Sat.?

sabbath my friend

starts tonight around 5 and ends about 6 saturday night

Ah, I see.

Always thought that was all day Sat. only. I’ll look for it Sat. night then.

mmhmm 25 hours about

and i suggest you do

I'm down.

Who do I make a sig for after Melvin serves up a beatdown?

hey im down to do a 2 for 1

Hey, how bad can it be? Chris 90210 survived a sig bet loss….of course, he had to change his member name to something else afterward, but still.

Bet menckenstein instead

he wants in on the action.

ill take you all on!!!

You're done son.

you sig is mine!!!!

Both of you, stop

why stop pre fight gloating??
No reason

I just wanted to post the most powerful being

We were getting a little carried away with the giant pics I guess.

ya i guess we can start with mini pics
Is Mr. majasdflajsodfjaosidfjs or whatever

more powerful than this guy?

If psychoblack keeps ducking me I'll take you up on the sigbet

Standing by. Offer good until either the fight starts or someone else claims it. I’m browsing NSFW sites right now for sig material.

For "sig material" ? SUUUUURE
Am I missing something obvious?

“eighteen of his first twenty-four foes, finishing fourteen handily, with four losses, two draws and one No Contest”

24
-4 losses
- 2 draws
- 1 no contest

Did he devour the no contest guy or something? Been a long day, probably me just being stupid.

Melvin went 14-3-1 in his first 18 fights. Ol’ Dallas just got mixed up and turned around with an odd half-breakdown of his career.

You know what I've always found to be stupid?

Counting.

if guillard fights super cautious

like he did against stephens, i think he straight up takes this.

if not, well, he’s getting choked out.

Slap yo self

Ya’ll ain’t fading Guillard.

against jim miller i be fading all day
against jim miller i be fading all day
with every one of these stories

I get closer to logging into playground to change my picks.

But screw it. CAN’T FADE GUILLARD!

I admire your dedication

But you’re costing your team points. That’s a paddlin’.

Well

If everybody else picks Miller, and I’m the dummy who picks Guillard, maybe my score won’t count. OR maybe I’m a genius.

Probably the former though.

Paddlin’ the school canoe? Ooooh you know that’s a paddlin’.

dont fade him! its better for us :)
Guillard's to risky of a bet

If his chin gets touched solidly…he crumbles…the guy just can’t take a hit well.

I haven’t seen his earlier fights to know if it happened before, but Joe Stevenson dropped him with a punch that wasn’t exactly loaded up or a power shot and then choked him out.

Since he tested positive for cocaine and etc after that fight…you could consider it an outlier.

But then Lauzon, again, landed a punch that was more of a jab than anything else, but Melvin ran right into it…was hurt badly and lost his composure…leading to the first round sub.

Throughout his career, Melvin Guillard has been submitted 8 times…8 of his 9 losses are by submission.

Of those 8 submission losses, 7 were in the first round. We know that at LEAST two of them he was rocked in.

The odds of him being either overwhelmed purely with grappling or getting tagged and then overwhelmed with grappling just seem too high to comfotable pick him against dudes that are in the top 10.

Barry or morecraft?

I'm going with Barry

I mean…that is almost entirely based on that I like the dude. Because a victory for either guy is pretty justifiable.

Morecraft could muscle him to the ground and sub or GNP him. I’m sure Barry has improved his overall grappling, but until we SEE it on display…I don’t have enough confidence in it to be used in much more than surviving for X amount of time.

Barry hits hard and he hits fast…he has a fast leg kick, a fast high kick, and a fast right hand(I’m pretty sure he is orthodox and not a southy) and Morecraft has been TKO/KO’d in 2 of his UFC fights….so I don’t think he has the chin to take a good HW strike(many don’t) so Barry could put him out.

So in a tough fight, I don’t really hesitate to go with who I’m rooting for more.

So not to totally derail this discussion but

Kevin Randleman was just diagnosed with cancer? his twitter handle is @randle_monster

holy shit thats insane best wishes to him!!!!

Gave it to himself…that’s what Sonnen told me

Here's the link to his twitter

He’s at least keeping it positive

http://twitter.com/randle_monster

which type of cancer did he say?
Undisclosed, didn't even say it was cancer 100% but that's the only illness he's brought up in comparisons
damn thats awful wish him the best again

ppl actually picked Melvin?
Big mistake

You must Login with your SB Nation account and be a member of Bloody Elbow to post a comment.