SB Nation - Login for mobile commenting

Bloody Elbow

The Best MMA Writing of 2011: Fraser Coffeen and Ben Thapa Talk Technique in the Judo Chop Series

TORONTO, ON - DECEMBER 10: (L-R) Referee Herb Dean calls for a doctor after Antonio Rodrigo Nogueira suffered a separated shoulder from an arm lock against Frank Mir during the UFC 140 event at Air Canada Centre on December 10, 2011 in Toronto, Ontario, Canada. (Photo by Nick Laham/Zuffa LLC/Zuffa LLC via Getty Images)

TORONTO, ON - DECEMBER 10: (L-R) Referee Herb Dean calls for a doctor after Antonio Rodrigo Nogueira suffered a separated shoulder from an arm lock against Frank Mir during the UFC 140 event at Air Canada Centre on December 10, 2011 in Toronto, Ontario, Canada. (Photo by Nick Laham/Zuffa LLC/Zuffa LLC via Getty Images)

There's something I feel I should get out of the way, to prepare myself for whatever criticisms, both valid and bizarre, that are sure to come. One is that this "best of" list is meant to be comprehensive, but it's meant to be comprehensive in accordance with my own tastes. In other words, it's a personal list.

In addition, "writing" will not always be featured. At the time of putting together this list, I had only writing in mind, but as I went through some great features (like some of Helwani's interviews, and Jack Encarnacao's Rewind series), I felt like this series needed to represent great and interesting work regardless of category.

Hence why I included Luke Thomas' interviews with Henry Cejudo and Jordan Burroughs the other day. It's true my intelligence (or lackthereof) doesn't deserve the benefit of the doubt, but I'm aware of the difference between writing and transcription. Now, to those annoyed by the inclusion of BE work I'll do you one better: I'll admit my unabashed love for this site.

As a longtime reader of Bloody Elbow, I've found it to be the one place I could stomach being around MMA fans (who I typically sort of despise). The bar hasn't been set high when you contrast this place with say, Sherdog.net (a place that feels like it was created by The Onion to parody internet trolls), but BE has been a fantastic source for discussion among its educated readers (some of whom will actually be featured on this list).

If there's a reason for that, you can probably trace it back to one of the staples of BE: the Judo Chop. For some of us, but especially for casual fans, it's often difficult to decipher the action in the cage. The arts themselves are complicated enough. Who actually knows that Ryo Chonan's submission win over Anderson Silva is technically a flying kesa besama into an inverted heelhook? Not I.

And so it's always interesting to learn just what exactly the fighters themselves have learned, and how they use that information to create violence.

Two Judo Chops that I feel stood out more than others this year were Fraser Coffeen's look at Anderson Silva at UFC 134 and his use of the "anchor punch", and Ben Thapa's begrudging analysis of Frank Mir's submission win over Antonio Nogueira at UFC 140.

Star-divide

The inclusion of Anderson Silva in a Judo Chop seems almost formulaic. Even Silva's more bizarre performances involve incredible acts. But it's also a testament to his arsenal.

While we mock (and rightfully so) the comparison of any modern athlete with zero cultural impact to Muhammad Ali, it's nonetheless worth noting that Silva bares at least a few similarities to the boxing icon from a technique standpoint. Namely, the use of the anchor punch: a strike that almost carries with it an urban legend status. For many boxing fans at the time, the punch had more sinister associations: as evidence that the fight was fixed (given the speed and seemingly delicacy with which it was thrown). Here's Fraser with the breakdown of Ali's use of it:

You see Ali, hands low, dodge Liston's left with quick head movement. As he dodges, he brings the right hand up and around, connecting square on Liston. Ali also moves slightly to his right with the punch, putting himself at an angle to Liston, who is moving forward. Ali throws that punch over Liston's extended punching arm, guaranteeing Liston won't be able to defend it. The combination of Liston's forward motion and Ali's clean shot are enough to put Liston down. If there's still any doubt that the punch lands, watch the way the force of the punch ripples all down Liston's right side.

Switching gears from a more graceful violence to a raw and brutal one: enter Frank Mir at UFC 140.

The sequence is still fresh in everyone's minds. Mir gets rocked. Nog rolls for a guillotine. Mir escapes by rolling which leads to Nog attempting to sit-out which leads to Nog going for back control, which Mir counters with a kimura. What did Nog do wrong in this sequence? It's hard to believe a grappler of Nog's caliber would make such a mistake, but here's Thapa with the breakdown:

The wrestling-style sit out allows a fighter to use the slightly askew center of gravity of the opponent on top to sprawl sitting up towards one particular side - and potentially offers avenues to rear mount or at least a bodylock on a turned away opponent. This particular sit out is nicely timed and showcases the more recent vintage of grappling the Nogueira brothers now train. However, Big Nog leaves his right arm down low, between Mir's legs. The left hand is controlling Mir's right hand nicely and the body is sprawled out in good fashion. The only weak link is that right hand. It should be up around Mir's waist and tight to the body.

It's a sequence that has likely earned Mir a submission of the year, and for good reason: he submitted one of the most respected BJJ practitioners, while dazed no less.

You can read Fraser's full breakdown here. He can be found on twitter @FCoffeen.

Ben Thapa's piece can be read here. His twitter account: @DefGrappler.

0 recs  |  27 comments

Comments

WTF?!?

The british sensation Kj Gould gets no love in the title???? Boo booooooooo! Sure he likes pretending wrestling had a closed guard, but that’s no reason to snub him on award day.

I'm gonna do

a ‘best interviews’ kind of thing, and Gould’s work with interviewing the Snake Pit is the one that stands out for me.

Just not as you know it

lol

Nice!

That picture is in dire need of some perspective...

Dire, I say.

it was taken at the Blue Oyster Bar
Ahh ... the maddening allure of the Chop

They literally brought me to BE. Every time I wanted to cover a slice of something awesome, a Google search would lead me to one of Kid Nate’s Chops and that’s how we first started talking.

It’s still my favorite feature on BE by miles, and the two you selected definitely stand out. Nice write up.

They are indeed.

It’s cool that there is a place where I can find a good measure of an education on the sport. And for free.

If only 141 had some damn submissions… given Hettes pretty much judo clinic’d Nam for 3 rounds.

Do chops on positional control too!

Thanks to all judo chop writers

As it is for many I’m sure, it is my favorite piece on BE. I imagine these take quite a bit of work and expertise.

I think it also take some guts to breakdown thesse moves on an mma site lurking with experts in every area. I remember some of Kid Nate’s early chops, his breakdowns were great, but he was also open and welcomed input from the community. Thanks again.

Don’t apologise for including BE on your best of MMA writing of the year list. Apologise for having anything other than BE on it

I finally got a computer that wasn’t too slow to handle GIFs, and I’ve been working my way back through the last year’s Judo Chops and they’re amazing. Thanks to all of the knowledgeable writers who put them together!

Just want to say

Judo Chops make Bloody Elbow stand head and shoulders above the rest of the pack of MMA blogs.

The historical, cultural, and technical diagrams and discussions are unmatched.

it's a proud day to see my baby standing on his own!
Ha ha

My grandpa said the exact same thing when his almost as-good-as-dead penis showed some signs of survival… :)

D00d...how do you even know this?

Wait…don’t tell me.

All in the fmily...

It became a family matter… my grandma thought she was safe when she hid the Viagra. Apparently, she wasn’t…

The best thing about knowledge

is sharing it with others. When a Judo Chop is well-written and offers informative GIFs and diagrams, people like me are able to more easily understand what’s going on. Then I watch an event with less informed friends, I try to explain what’s going on, and we all become better MMA fans. That’s why these pieces are among the best in MMA, because when they’re well done they increase the potential audience and our understanding of the sport.

The anchor punch article is a great example. I shared those GIFs and the information there with at least 10 other people who have never been to BE before, and at least one of them purchased the very next UFC PPV.

You are a great sneezer.

High five!

Nog Chop over Shogun Deep Half Chop? You loved the emotional component of this one, David.

Porra!

I did

but I also think it’s a nice reference for another award: submission of the year, which Mir deserves. The idea of “great MMA grappling” is a strange one because if you’re measuring it by MMA success, then the ‘grappling’ element is irrelevant.

For a good illustration of this consider Frank Mir’s win over World Jiu Jitsu champion, Roberto Traven. Traven was an accomplished grappler, and submitting him is an accomplishment I’d consider far more impressive than any of Nog’s submission wins. But a submission win in an MMA fight doesn’t exist in a vacuum: in fact, Mir dropped Traven prior to submitting him (though Traven wasn’t hurt as bad as Mir was against Nog, which is why I still consider it impressive). So how do you resolve that “conflict” in deciding that Mir isn’t better than Nog in that context?

Traven never transferred his BJJ grappling over to MMA well. He’s much like Kevin Jackson in that respect.

Also, Mir’s technique in submitting just about everyone – except Nog and Lesnar – was abominable. He’s a very strong guy in terms of holding onto limbs and necks, but the technique is kind of “Eh, get the job done.” Also, Nog uses his grappling better than Mir does to stay upright, get out of bad positions and/or stay in top position.

I meant to preface

that statement with “hey, I’ve got a bone to pick with you on the other Mir article”, but you get where I’m going. But yes, both were fantastic breakdowns.

You must Login with your SB Nation account and be a member of Bloody Elbow to post a comment.