SB Nation - Login for mobile commenting

Bloody Elbow

Junior Dos Santos Still a Betting Favorite Over Alistair Overeem

Photo

A few weeks before UFC 141, betting site Bookmaker decided to cover both sides of the coin and put out a line for two future UFC heavyweight title bouts: Junior dos Santos vs. Brock Lesnar, and Junior dos Santos vs. Alistair Overeem. This way, people could get in on the action as early as possible. If they bet on Brock vs. JDS, they just got a refund since the bout will never happen, so no big loss. What is interesting is how much (or little) the line on Overeem vs. JDS has changed since Saturday night, and that Dos Santos is still the favorite.

Back when the line originally dropped (before UFC 141), it looked like this:

Overeem +190
Dos Santos -240

As of this morning, it looks like this:

Overeem +147
Dos Santos -177

While that is a substantial difference, I frankly expected a lot more of a swing. It's true that the bout hasn't been officially announced yet, and that this line is from one particular site (Pinnacle is the only other site to drop a line so far, after UFC 141, and it has JDS at -155, Overeem at +140), but I expect to see this line end up close to even by the time the fight rolls around. I'm sure some will find that ridiculous, but that's truly what I see happening.

Basically, if you have some disposable income and you think Alistair Overeem is going to defeat Junior dos Santos, now is the time to make that bet. And if you're leaning toward dos Santos, wait it out. Today's betting advice was brought to you by the letters A and O, and the number 1.

0 recs  |  281 comments

Comments

So what you’re sayin is that everyone on BE should take out all there money and drop it on Overeem. To the bank I go!

You still have to go to the bank to get your money?

It's a close fight I think

Even money I’d take JDS but at these odds Overeem is definitely worth playing a unit or two.

What was wrong with JDS' knee again? MCL repair?

Gonna wait until open workouts or something before I decide on this.

Nah, it was just minor surgery. He says he’s close to 100% again.

Doesn't everyone say that though?

Not this quickly.

Partially torn meniscus IIRC

Correct

Very minor as knee injuries go.

as he should be

Nothing in the Brock fight showed that he should be favored over JDS. Mainly due to the style difference but still, Junior has fought far superior competition.

JDS always stays on the feet.

This is going to be a K-1 match with small gloves.

I think "far superior competition" is a huge stretch.

JDS hasn’t encountered a striker of Overeem’s pedigree, whereas Reem has fought numerous strikers that are as good or better than JDS. I would say JDS has fought and beaten higher level wrestlers, but that’s about it. I love both fighters and can’t wait for this fight, but I think Dos Santos is going to have a hell of time with Reems striking, especially since Reem won’t have to worry about the takedown.

JDS hasn’t encountered a striker of Overeem’s pedigree, whereas Reem has fought numerous strikers that are as good or better than JDS.

He fought those strikers in a different sport.

That doesn’t mean you completely throw it out the window.

No you can't

But you still have to take it with a grain of salt.

Striking works differently in MMA. That isn’t conjecture, that’s fact.

it works differently when you're fighting someone who goes for takedowns maybe.

JDS doesn’t do that.;

It works differently regardless

See my response to Ak.Death, there are so many more variables in MMA than in K-1, more than just takedowns.

That is insane

The size of the gloves and the clinch game add completely different aspects of striking in MMA.

If Overeem covers up the same way he does in K-1 against JDS, JDS is going to murder him. He will be able to slip punches past his guard like a lot of strikers have been able to do.

shogun used near that exact guard against machida.

Forearm shield is fine for mma.

forearm sheild is fine

peekaboo is not… which is what Reem did in K-1. He hasn’t fought with that kind of gaurd in MMA though, so people acting like he does is kind of silly

yes it does...

and to be specific he always gets destroyed by strikers in MMA.. I.E chuck, rua etc…

Is that really a bad comparison when you consider the fact that most people think JDS vs. Reem will go down like a K-1 fight in the octagon?

But it won't go down like a K-1 fight in the cage

Because there will be clinching against the fence, if someone gets knocked down there will be follow-up strikes on the ground. There will be opportunities for standing submissions (Overeem’s patented guillotine anyone?) and there is always the threat that one of these guys will actually try to take it to the ground if the standup isn’t working for them.

Point taken

and I do realize that MMA and K-1 striking are totally different. The point I was trying to make was that it’s ridiculous to say that JDS has faced far superior competition, Alistair has 3x as many fights, and has squared off with more dangerous strikers than JDS has. Has Reem fought some guys that had no business in the ring with him over the years? Absolutely. That shouldn’t take away from the fact that he has more experience fighting elite strikers than Dos Santos has, and that is a huge factor in this fight. Not trying to take anything away from JDS resume, he has been unstoppable in the no. 1 MMA organization in the world so far, but he has yet to be matched up with someone whose striking skills are equal or even better than his.

They will be striking but there is always the chance of a takedown...

Kinda like when chuck unexpectedly took wanderlei down..

When Overeem faces good strikers in MMA

He normally loses.

to be fair

It would be after he gassed at LHW. He was beating liddel up then gassed and got dropped. It was kinda his MO

I find it hard to believe that his gas tank is better at heavyweight when he is carrying around more muscle.

It's been

demonstratively better

When has he gone into deep waters at Heavyweight

The Werdum fight (where he gassed). That is about the only fight I can remember at heavyweight where we have seen his cardio.

Paul Buentello

off the top of my head.

It’s hard to gas in a fight that is a one sided beatdown.

It wasn't hard for him to gass giving one sided beatdowns as a LHW

which is the point…

So your point is that his cardio went from really bad to below average?

Dude, do you know what the word "better" means?

Still doesn’t say much about his cardio against high level competition, which he is now facing in the UFC.

That's not even the conversation we were having.
Oh yeah, you're right

I might be a little high right now to be fair.

Who said anything about deep waters?

He normally gassed right near the end or after the first round. If he goes three without gasping for air, he’s already better than during his LHW days.

seriously

People saying this never watched him in Pride.

People assume the heavyweight version of Overeem is so much different than his LHW incarnation

And that is simply not true.

His first five minutes in Pride were glorious almost against everyone he faced. That alone makes his move to become a Hulk at HW a great idea, because his chances of a finish increase.

I find it hard to believe you have ever cut major weight. Like 20lbs. In 24 hrs. If you had…. Then you wouldn’t say that.

Damn, maybe I should learn more about betting and make some quick and easy money.

it ain't easy if you don't know who's gonna win
MMA

makes me wish I had one of those Sports Almanac from Back to the Future.

I wish for this every day
Every. Day.

Sigh….so much money….so much money

JDS hasn't faced

a striker as good as Overeem before and it will be an interesting test of the two to see who the best striker in the heavyweight divison is. I think about even odds is right because someone is going to get KO’d in the first 3 rounds and I have no idea which one.

That's because AO is in a league of his own

when it comes to striking, but JDS has stood, traded and won against Carwin, Roy, Yvel, CC (yeah I know, but still…) and Cain, very competent mma strikers. Didn’t AO get outstruck by…Werdum?

Uhhhh

Didn’t AO outstike Hari, Aerts (twice), Spong, Texeira and others?

Didn’t AO not get hurt at all by being “outstruck” by Werdum?

Two different sports with different rules, techniques and equipment

ummmmm.....

Really?? That’s your answer??

Seems like a reasonable answer to me.

Larger gloves and not being worried about a takedown surely count for something?

i

Would agree except he is a grappler that became a kickboxer. Did he look worried against Brock? From my angle he didn’t look worried.
The striking stance of reem is nearly identical in K1 and mma. So are the results: victory at HW. Muay Thai scores throws from the clinch. Its not a one dimensional art like boxing.

Word

Although Overeem might be standing up even straighter in this fight, with his hands up in front of his chin.

JDS will not be threatening any takedowns. He doesn’t want to and he wouldn’t be able to.

This means the only significant difference will be in terms of blocking. So, okay there is some difference. I suppose that means we should just throw the fact that Overeem is the reigning K-1 GP champion in the garbage? He’s the frickin reigning GP champion for God’s sake!!

I really feel like the dismissals of Overeem’s skills are based on some kind of perverse wishful thinking.

he won the GP more on his durability and muscle mass then his striking dominance.

Durablility and Muscle Mass?

Ha

It's the truth though.

AO was outstruck by Werdum like Anderson Silva was outstruck by Maia… in both cases, pure boredom explains it, IMO.

Lol, I wasn’t asking a rhetorical question or being a smart ass, I really wanted to know. I didn’t see the fight, but I remember reading here on BE that according to Fightmetric, Werdum outstruck AO.

werdum

Had a fantasicly boring,yet effective idea. He would come in and tag Reem and pull guard when Reem countered. Reem would back away ref calls stand up. Rinse, repeat.
Judges say if you are on your back you lose. Kinda the story.

Overeem also hit him pretty hard. But, if you fall down every time someone throws a punch at you, let alone hits you, it’s hard to pick out the actual knockdowns. Overeem landed fewer punches but clearly hit much cleaner and harder.

even if they were really good shots ....

Doesn’t matter if you can’t follow to the ground and follow up. I am the only person on the planet that liked that fight I think.

I enjoyed it

I was curious if Overeem would build the courage to dive into Werdum’s guard, or if Werdum would finally commit to standing and trading. It was an entertaining clash of styles and gameplans.

I was waiting for Overeem to grab one of Werdum’s legs and start dragging him around the cage…

LOL, no
Didn’t AO get outstruck by…Werdum?
What makes you think Overeem is a better bet now than he was before 141?

Lasnar didn’t put up much of a fight. I think the bookies have this one right and can’t see the odds changing that much.

The bookies only set the original line

The odds change based on where the money goes.

Oh OK. Maybe I shouldn't comment on American betting articles.

It’s different in Europe, where bookies often slash the odds as and when they feel like it.

Anyway I still think the Lesnar fight proves little for Overeem. As Rogan was saying in commentary Overeem had absolutely no respect for Lesnar’s stand up. JDS has awsome stand up.

Yeah, but Reem could have sat back in fear and not used knees or kicks against Brock in fear of the takedown, yet instead he went right at him. Lesner didn’t put up much of a fight because Overeem didn’t let him. You can say Lesner’s heart wasn’t in it as he was thinking retirement, but I still got respect Reem for taking him out in under 3 minutes in the way that he did.

I caught Reem at -130 odds against Lesner, and dropped some on him at +170 against Dos Santos. I agree with this article,…..will get closer as fight gets near.

Overeem Will Be Kicking Like Mad

Try and Keep Distance again JDS, especially considering Overeem has been dropped before

probably alternating between that and clinching up.

staying out of that medium range will be key for him.

He may also throw big overhands and hooks

But he would be foolish to sit in boxing range and try to trade tit for tat.

I'm supporting JDS on this.

I would like to see the HW strap defended for a while.

Yeah if Reem wins, he'll most likely lose to Cah-yeen.
I think Overeem would beat Cain.

Stuff the takedown and then outclass him on the feet. So far when hes fought good strikers he almost got ktfo multiple times by Kongo (but kongo had no clue how to stop the takedown) and ko’d by JDS. I’d count Nog in there but he was zombie Nog in that fight.

Overeem / Cain would be very interesting.

If Cain has learned from his fight with JDS, he’ll go back to his wrestling roots. I think Cain sort of fell in love with his own striking, which wrestlers tend to do once they ko a few people. Brock was supposed to test Overeem’s TDD, but that single leg he tried on Overeem was so half-assed. You won’t see that sort of thing from Cain. Either way, it would make for an awesome fight.

First off, very few people shoot in the first minute of an MMA fight

Especially when they are fighting a good fighter.

I think Cain can beat up Overeem. If you thought Overeem was tentative against Werdum, he would be just as much so against Cain. Cain has better takedowns than Werdum, and better striking.

Why would Overeem be as tentative as he was against Werdum? He was avoiding the ground because he feared the submission as Werdums only path to victory. He did not fear the takedown or ground control. He’d probably fight Cain like he fought Brock.

Not really. Part of the reason Overeem was tentative wasn’t because Werdum was flopping, it was because Werdum was shooting. A lot.

Because of the submissions...ffs

Overeem didn’t commit on his strikes as much as usual because he didn’t want to get taken down. This wouldn’t change if he fought Velasquez.

Yes it will

because getting taken down by Werdum is WAY worse than being taken down by Cain.

No

Cain Velasquez has an uncanny ability to punch a guy in the face a million times before the guy gets up. With Overeem’s chin and cardio, that is going to hurt him fast. Even if Overeem gets up if Cain takes him down he is going to eat a lot of shots trying to do it.

Cain Velasquez also had the uncanny ability to let himself get tagged by Kongo every round so hard he had to shoot for the desperation-takedown.

Overeem was tentative against Werdum because he feared Fabricio would school him on the ground. If Werdum locks up a submission it is over. Defending Cains strikes and getting up is certainly not what Overeem wants but the threat of a fight-ending situation is not as dire because he will have much more trust in his skillset to fend off Cains attack. He’d fight him like he fought Brock: very low stance, training TDD as hard as he can before and force a standup-battle. The only difference being that Cain will fare much better standing with AO than Brock did. Ultimately though he would probably lose.

The Kongo fight was 2 1/2 years ago. Cain is definitely much improved since then.

Cain’s striking has come a LONG way.

How can you tell?

From blitzing Nog and Brock? Or by getting stomped by JDS? Cain has certainly improved. But to the point he wouldn’t get clowned again on the feet by the truly elite strikers? Not sure.

To me it looked like Cain wanted to test his standup against JDS first.

Right after the fight, nearly everyone thought Cain should have shot right away. Set it up with a couple punches then shoot. But he didn’t. Even Kos criticized his game plan.

Also, Cain said taking JDS down wasn't going to be the gameplan.

From MMA Mania:

If (the opportunity) is there I’ll take it, but that’s not the game plan going in. He is good in that position, but I’m not afraid to put him in that position. If I don’t get it, I’m going to stand up with him, punch with him and kick with him.

He shoulda straight up wrestled with him.

Cain was going after JDS' injured knee

JDS talked about it post-fight, the number of kicks that Cain directed at his knee, and he guessed that Cain knew that he could barely walk a week before the fight.

I don’t think Cain forgot his wrestling roots, his game plan was to attack the injured body part in the early part of the fight. Kind of like how Overeem’s plan was knees to Brock’s surgically repaired midsection- that’s some mental shit as well as physical. Get the guy to hesitate and be tentative.

I understand how on paper Reem is the better standup striker and has more tools, and this is obviously a close fight, but speed kills and JDS has the fastest strikes between the two fighters. I think his hands will be able to counter some of Overeem’s kicks, they will be effective in the clinch or off the break, and they will be deadly at his optimal range. I think that will be the difference in the fight.

Reem would’ve thrown these knees in any case. He used to win by throwing mostly knees even in K1 and is able to KO guys with knees to the body. I’d say the same is true for Cain as well. It’s certainly possible he knew about Junior’s injury but leg-kicking JDS was a good idea in any case.

Yeah, whether he knew about the injury or not, leg kicks made sense. It’s just he should have shot as well. Hindsight is 20/20 I guess.

Well in this case it’s a bit more since everybody knew wrestling JDS was the smart move. I guess everybody thought he’d fare much better standing against Junior though. That he got blown out like that was a surprise.

Still don’t know how healthy he was, too.

Dos Santos should be the favorite but in a fight with striker vs striker, anything can happen

Reem will be a lot stronger unless JDS goes horsemeat for a while here. Not sure that matters outside round 1.

We’ve seen both of them get tired. Who knows.

JDS doesn't have bad cardio, especially for a HW

Cigano has won every round he’s fought in the UFC. He slowed down a little after using Roy Nelson as a punching bag for two rounds, but he didn’t look gassed at all. Same with the Carwin fight. I’ll take JDS’s quickness and cardio over Reem’s and I’ll definitely take JDS in a longer fight, if that’s how it plays out.

This meme needs to die

He landed more strikes on Nelson in round 3 than he did in round 1 and took Carwin down twice in round 3.

JDS’ cardio is not bad nor has he ever been really tired.

Never said his cardio was bad

I said we’ve seen him tired, which is true. He kept his composure and stuck to his gameplan, he didn’t try anything crazy to try and end it quickly or wilt. Also most of the reason he landed more punches in round 3 against Nelson is because Roy was just walking straight at JDS and threw the same punch over and over.

Are you serious

Someone threw more punches than Roy Nelson in a 3rd round and THAT’S how you want to measure if they got tired or not?!

"On" him, not "than" him
Does that matter?

SS said that in the third round, Junior landed more strikes on Roy than he did in the first. I would assume that’s evidence that Junior wasn’t gassing so hard his offense was stifled.

Whether you take that to mean Roy’s defense crumbled by round 3 or Junior’s offense wasn’t diminished is up to you. I assumed the latter.

Ahhh, I get it

It still seems like an insane barometer, but it makes a lot more sense now.

Absolutely

and he certainly outclasses Reem in that aspect.

Man idk

JDS is a fucking brute as well. I’m not so sure that AO will be a LOT stronger, maybe by a bit though.

JDS is a big boy, and I don't think the strength difference is going to be all that pronounced

or important. Overeem should have the advantage if he gets in the clinch, but ultimately they’re each plenty strong enough to put the other to sleep.

I don't think you guys know how Overeem trains

He’s extremely strong for a person his size.

Watch his training videos. He works out with Dutch strongman. That’s the elite level in strength training.

I’ve seen him deadlift nearly 700lbs with ease. His functional strength really seems to be off the charts for a 260lbs combat athlete. He’s more comparable to an elite NFL defensive lineman.

I remember being surprised after he practically threw Brett Rogers during their fight. Manhandling a guy Rogers’ size is an impressive feat.

I doubt there’ll be a better bet than Nate Diaz at 2-1 to beat Cerrone for a whie, but Overeem comes close at those odds. JDS is a great guy, but he stood and teed off for 15 minutes on both Carwin and Nelson and didn’t look like getting a stoppage, an elite pro boxer or K1 striker like Overeem would have finished both fights.
JDS could clip Alistair on the chin, but other than that i see Overeem taking this one.

Just to increase my credibility with you guys slightly (from like 0% to 0.1%), I was most definitely telling people to bet on Diaz and Hettes at 141.

Bet on Hettes on PG, now I’m really wishing I did for real.

Yep I also said that Hettes was easy money.
I think you mean Codit not Cerrone.
Condit*

Nah, he means Cerrone. He’s referring to Nate Diaz at UFC 141.

Nate was a 2 to 1 underdog? Wow. He was my pick but I didn't see him being so dominant.

I got him at +240.

Reem's chin is nowhere near as good as Nelson or Carwin.

Seriously, if JDS can connect with one of those uppercuts or power hooks, Reem is out. I think Reem will fight very smart and respect JDS’ power however. He’ll make it very tough for JDS to hit him.

Badr Hari hit Reem pretty hard in 2010

He scored some light knockdowns, but it wasn’t lights out.

Don’t know what would’ve happened if Badr had been allowed to follow up with strikes on the ground though.

a guillotine from guard

lol. maybe. If AO gets it on Badr, the fight is over, that’s for sure. :)

Carwin allegedly had decent standup and he got made to look like a fool. Nelson is just damn near impossible to kfto. I love Ubereem but if he gets caught with that same punch that he hit Cain with he’s not dropping to the floor and staring back at JDS, he’s falling face first and not waking up for the next 3 mins.

Carwin allegedly had decent standup

What?

I see another 1 minute victory for JDS.

He’s my man crush. No homo, but… well a little.

JDS has a ton of quality wins under his belt

His last seven fights are:

Werdum, Struve, Cro Cop, Yvel, Gonzaga (all finished), Nelson, Carwin, Cain.

That is nuts. I am not sure there is another MMA HW out there with a list of wins like that, outside of maybe fedor, mir, or maybe big nog. cain and brock only have about 4 quality wins.

Having said that – he is just not a big heavyweight. Despite all he has accomplished, I have trouble really believing in him. I thought he would lose to Cain. AO will be a steep test, as will be Mir. But if he gets through those fights … man. You’re talking HW GOAT right there.

cormier

might be an interesting challenge when he comes over.

The winner of Cormier - Barnett, really

Though I think either one of them would make credible challengers if they can pick up a top 5 win.

Definitely the best active resume

If he wins the upcoming fights, he might have the best record ever.

But, I don’t understand why so many writers see JDS as the favorite against Overeem. Sure, Overeem hasn’t beaten the fighers that JDS has, but that has little to do with how they match up. Overeem is the worst possible matchup for JDS.

how so?
He's the only one with better kickboxing

I’m not saying JDS can’t win. I’m just saying I don’t understand why he would be favored. Overeem has proven that he can take shots in K-1. I also think he’s proven that he’s never without weapons and that those weapons are probably the most powerful in the business.

JDS beat carwin and cro cop by fighting in such a way that they weren’t able to do anything effective against him. I don’t see how he could do that to Overeem.

I agree. I think JDS has the better boxing skillset but this is MMA. AO is the best heavyweight MMA kickboxer and isn't too shaby on the ground either. What I don't get is the whole no chin talk, AO hasn't been rocked since he's packed on all that muscle.
out of his HW fights...

who did you expect to touch his chin? Oh- and his Kharitonov KO loss was his first fight as a HW. If he was rocked by Goodrich, Hunt, Sylvester, Thomspson, Fujita, etc., then we wouldn’t even be having a discussion about his chances in this fight.

I don't get it . . .

He has been hit very hard by Badr Hari, Gokhan Saki, tyrone Spong and others. It did very little damage to him.

You can talk all you want about how the striking doesn’t translate exactly, but that has nothing to do with getting hit hard and reacting to it.

Saki's spinning heel kick should have been a knockdown...

and he was crippled. He fell flat on his face in the first knockdown from Hari in their 2nd fight. Sponge rocked him though he weighed about 50 lbs less…. a guys chin doesn’t just get better with muscles, and all of the examples you cited were K-1…different story with the smaller gloves.

Obviously a guy's chin DOES get better with something AO has

You completely distort every event you describe. Overeem did not fall on his face against Hari. Saki’s heel kick put Overeem on his butt, sitting up and he popped up instantly. Spong did not rock him seriously at any point in their 3 round fight.

Instead, Overeem took heavy shots from all of those guys without it doing that much damage to him, considering what he was hit with.

How can you say that his chances of being KO'd by elite HW MMA fighters...

is diminished based on the K-1 evidence? Rewatch the Hari fight right now (I just watched it last night) and watch the first knockdown. What do you call putting someone on their butt due to the force of a strike, even if they recover quickly? Oh yeah….that’s a knockdown. And you added the qualifier “seriously” to the Spong reference- I only said that he was rocked, and he was… he was forced to regain his balance along the ropes as Spong fired unanswered hooks. Granted, he survived it, and was never in any danger of losing the fights, but what you see as ironclad evidence that Reem’s chin is reborn, I’m still seeing evidence that it’s a liability. We haven’t seen him hit by a top-tier MMA fighter at HW yet… using K-1 fights to prove a point is a fruitless endeavor.

Oh- and your assessment of small vs. large gloves is, er, let’s just say distorted.

Well

I guess we’re not going to interpret these things the same way.

I just watched the Hari knockdown about ten times in a row. Hari hits him and then they get tangled for half a second and when they sort of come loose, Overeem falls down forward. It’s not exactly a trip, but Overeem does not fall down on his face in a daze.

Why would using K-1 fights to prove a fighter’s ability to take a shot be a fruitless endeavor? Do you just mean that, as a matter of fact, Overeem’s particular history in K-1 does not prove this? or, do you mean that it could not prove it no matter what, because, you know, k-1 is different and stuff?

If it’s the second thing you’re claiming, I think that’s crazy.

And I'm not denying that Sakhi knocked him down

I’m only saying that, given the kind of strike that was, Overeem took it really well.

Wasn’t it proven that the smaller gloves may have a bit less padding and smaller area of effect but that is offset by the higher weight of the bigger gloves so that in the end, the impact they make on the target if almost identical in terms of KO-potenital? I seem to remember a science-studi from some thai-university somebody linked to once.

I remember that too

and it REALLY counter-intuitive. I can’t find it again, though.

Is it? I dunno if you ever fought with the bigger gloves but you it’s not like you’re slamming big cushions into your opponent. You can clearly feel the impact area increase and decrease when turning your hand so that you land with the approproiate two or three knuckles of your hand (or whatever, depending on the strike). So IMO it’s not that hard to believe.

I've boxed

not a lot, but I sparred for a few years as a teenager. I always felt I hit people harder, and did more damage, in fistfights.

I’ve only hit the bag barehanded. You feel the impact more immediately in your hand and wrist. But in terms of how the bag reacts to the force, not sure if there was a difference.

Plus, maybe it’s of no consequence if we’re arguing KO-potential anyway because a KO is more about the momentum imparted than about concentrating power in one spot as it would be for breaking bones or cutting, I suppose?

You’re right on that… In a fistfight you wouldn’t really care about scoring a KO. The larger glove may in fact force the brain to move more inside the skull. impact of your brain against the back of your skull and the subsequent rebound is what would cause loss of consciousness I believe.

Yeah. As I said, the study put it at about even. The impulse transmitted from glove / hand to the head relies on the mass and the speed. The smaller gloves are quicker, the bigger gloves are heavier and in the end, it equals out mostly. Area of impact is not as important, unless we’re talking skull-fracture, I guess. Been a while since I read into this stuff though.

uh...

Overeem’s chin is HIGHLY suspect.

When he was a undedicated LHW cutting 15 pounds. I thought neck muscle = chin?
Then what's James Thompson'ss excuse?

Neck muscle does not automatically equal a good chin, and Hari destroyed him with those neck muscles. Granted, getting beaten by Badr is no shameful act, but don’t you think that JDS with 4 oz. gloves poses at least that big a threat?

destroyed???

Com’mon son. That second" knock down" was no a mma style knock down. He wasn’t rocked, he just got knocked off balance and into the ropes. Let’s not act like it was some colossal destruction inflicted upon him.

Yes

Also, I know people talk about the danger of 4oz gloves but being hit by a larger object (bigger gloves) has MORE impact. It’s harder to block with smaller gloves but the momentum of the strike is less.

The big gloves mass is greater...

but it has less velocity. It’s like using a snowshoe vs. a high heel on a frozen lake- less surface area = more concentrated force.

It wasn't an MMA style knockdown...

because it wasn’t MMA. If it was, then Hari would’ve been pounding Overeem in the corner while he still had tweety birds flying around his head. He got knocked down (per K-1 rules) 3 times in less than 3 minutes. I’d say that was a destruction and I’m a Reem fan. He was never even in that fight. How bout this- it was a “domination.”

fair but he blocked

The kick that knocked him against the ropes. It was just the force that pushed him back.

Beating Struve, Mirko, Gilbert Yvel, and Gonzaga is nuts?

Whatever you say.

Ha ha. AO destroyed Mirko's nuts.
heavyweight is a shallow pool dude

we were treated to ben rothwell v. mark hunt on the main card of a ppv recently.

I guess Rogers and Duffee are world beaters…

Wasn’t Rogers was Top-10ish around the time of that fight? I can’t remember the rankings for Struve, CC, Yvel, or Gonzaga but I can’t see any of them being top 10 except Gonzaga, maybe.

Rogers was ranked as number 10 when he fought Fedor.

Ah, thanks for that. I wasn’t sure

Kind of crazy how the pendulum has swung back towards strikers at heavyweight

It seems like not that long ago Brock, Carwin and Cain were making a case that you had to have a wrestling background to be successful at heavyweight. Now it looks like whoever wins this has the chance to hold the title for awhile with no wrestling background at all.

I think that whichever guy wins this...

loses to Cain when they fight.

Completely possible

I hope that last fight can be chalked up to injury and time off and he gets back to 100% soon. I don’t know if he can be champion again, but I like the division better with him in top form.

That fight told us nothing about who would win the next one.

Ah, the joy of heavyweights

Everyone punch has a chance of ending the fight, and the better fighter doesn’t always win.

fixed
Ah, the joy of heavyweights MMA
True

But more true at heavyweight than anywhere else.

Agreed

I don’t see Dominic Cruz getting taken out of the top spot anytime soon.

Not giving Faber a chance to edge him out?

I dunno

Cruz’s high volume style is really MMA judging friendly, and he’s very hard to take down. I like Faber a lot, but I think we’ll see a similar result if they fight again.

I think on any given night, Cain can lose pretty easy to either of those guys

If he fought them both 10 times I’d expect him to take six, maybe seven each, but I think we’ve now seen that powerful, accurate strikers present a very real issue for Cain, especially if he can’t put them on the ground right away.

Man I just don't know.

The JDS/Cain fight is pretty much what I had envisioned and saying prior to them being locked in the cage. JDS is just a fucking tank. I just couldn’t and still can’t see Cain beating JDS, what’s weird is that I can see Cain beating AO. I can even see Mir beating AO. Outside of Overeem, I really can’t see any hw beating JDS atm…at least not any current UFC hw, I’m not too familiar with most of the Strikeforce hws though.

Great HW distance fight.

Far out, or close in, advantage Reem; punching distance, advantage JDS. Wrestling, cardio and chin I give to JDS. Submissions I give to Reem just because we have empirical evidence of his game, but would anyone be surprised if JDS ended up showing some great submission acumen? Either way, don’t see how this fight is boring My early lean is JDS TKo’ing Reem with his hands, but an AO TKO would not surprise me in the least.

K1 world grand prix winning striker vs. Guy who only uses punches and won’t look for/ get any takedowns…. My money is on the guy with less tools to win…

In all seriousness, free money on reem.

How’d the kickboxing vs. boxing thing work out for Cerrone? With guys as skilled at their craft as these 2 are, I don’t see any easy causal relationships (like the one you proposed) at play here.

JDS is no DIAZ. JDS gets tired after the 200th punch, :)
It's a valid comparison

JDS is the better conventional boxer and AO is the better kickboxer (as was/is the case with Diaz and Cerrone). Just knowing how to throw kicks does not automatically mean that you’re going to win the striking matchup, especially if JDS controls distance with his superior speed and movement.

agreed.

though I have to say that I was extremely impressed with Overeem’s quickness against Lesnar. He darted in and out amazingly fast, though he did have the speed/footwork advantage over Brock, which he will not against JDS.

Comparison is completely invalid. Overeem is the much better kickboxer, and Diaz and JDS styles are completely parallel. Diaz won because his swarming non stop pressure style overwhelmed Cerrone. I can 100% guarantee you JDS isn’t going to employ that strategy. He’s going to try and methodically pick Reem apart or end his night with a single shot.

so the only way for a boxer to beat a superior kickboxer is with a Diaz style?

No, it comes through controlling distance through footwork so that you make it a battle of hands. Whether that’s through constantly moving forward like Diaz, or staying at your hands distance without drifting into his kicking distance or the clinch, it’s the same ends. JDS is imminently capable of doing that to Overeem.

You’re terribly good at putting words in peoples mouth’s, you should work for fox. My argument summarized: JDS is going to be forced into having a technical striking match with Overeem, in which he has less chance to win than he does to lose. Reading comprehension bro.

Rational thought, broseph.

Completely irrational to think Overeem takes this one, you’re right. Completely rational to misread everything I post and act as if you know what my argument is when you have no clue.

Use your words, Hendo...

it’ll help give all of us a clue.

Scroll up, problem solved.

How about...

poop on your face, problem solved?

In all seriousness though, why didn’t you join the War this season?

ugh. I really wanted to. I did pretty well last season. But as I said in the thread, my pick em life was interfering with my MMA fan life. It all hit me when I found myself rooting for Koscheck to KO Hughes (because I bet on that happening). After the fight I just thought to myself “wtf is this pick em tournament doing to me?” and decided that enjoying the sport is more important than trying to be the most right.

I know what you mean.

I’m in too deep though… and it makes me give a shit about fights like Hettes-Phan. Win-lose situation.

True. It’s got ups and downs. But it turned my main event jitters from “OMG someone’s about to get hurt!” to “OMG i’m almost at 90 points!” and I didn’t appreciate that.

Not joining pick em this year was the first Intelligent/responsible decision I’ve made in years.

Striking noob here -- but I'm not sure it is valid

Diaz style works well at LW/WW, but I don’t think it scales up well with weight, when the other guy’s puncher’s chance increases rapidly. Cerrone planted Nate with a kick to the face IIRC — if that happened at HW it would likely end in a KO/TKO.

IMO if a headkick hits clean, it’s game over at almost any weight. If it doesn’t, in most cases it wasn’t thrown right or defended a bit(off balance, too little hip-movement, half-blocked, guy was moving away with the kick etc).

Dude, most heavyweights can’t even throw a leg kick.

Now I feel stupid. I completely forgot that Cerrone was a k1 GP champion and that JDS could go five rounds without getting tired.

And Overeem can go 5 rounds without getting tired?

I’m an Overeem fan hoping he wins, but your dismissal of JDS based purely on striking credentials is just ignorant.

Ignorant? you’re the one assuming I said that when I never did. My point is JDS won’t be able to keep that level of pressure on Overeem for more than a half a round. Please make sure you’re not putting words in peoples mouth’s when calling them ignorant.

K1 world grand prix winning striker vs. Guy who only uses punches and won’t look for/ get any takedowns…. My money is on the guy with less tools to win…

In all seriousness, free money on reem.

You’re only using only striking credentials as evidence that Reem’s is an easy winner here. No mention of chin or cardio, footwork or speed, shit- not even striking defence or efficiency. If you want to elaborate, feel free, but based on the words you’ve already written, I stand by my statement.

JDH picking JDS, i’m calling bias. Seriously, you make some great points, but i’m going to give Reem the benefit of the doubt regarding his stamina at heavyweight, i think 205 was an unnatural weight for a man of Overeems proportions, a bit like a malnourished teenaged Manny Pacquiao fighting at 112.
I think the clinch will be where Overeem takes advantage and does the damage to win the fight, but you know your stuff homie!

I'm picking Reem to win the fight.

I just have a problem with anyone saying that this fight is “easy money” or a cakewalk for Reem. JDS has earned more respect than that.

I’m a big AO fan, but his cardio in the Werdum fight scared the shit out of me. Hopefully this is a purely standup fight, in which I have much more faith in AO’s cardio.

I think you’re misinterpreting “easy money”. If you really think the reem is going to win, and he’s a 2 to 1 underdog, then your odds say it’s easy money. Not that you think JDS has no chance, just that the betting odds are completely astray from the actual fight odds.

In all honesty though

JDS doesn’t really need to go nonstop, full-pressure for 25 minutes…because usually he only needs a round or two.

I think Alistair will be fine as long as he keeps his damn hands up.

However, I don’t think he felt Lesnar was a stand-up threat and was also waiting to defend the takedown. I think he’ll be more covered and protected with JDS.

If I was Alistair, I’d keep JDS at bay with kicks, work in the clinch if he got close and take him down if things started going awry standing. Overeem does have the size advantage and BJJ chops to do fairly well on the ground.

But, this is all suspect if Overeem strokes his ego and just decides to stand the whole time.

"Today's betting advice was brought to you by the letters A and O, and the number 1"

Today’s post was brought to you by the letters B and E and B I A S.

I’m a sports fan, not a commentator. I’m allowed to be biased :)

Someone doesn’t understand what a joke is, apparently.

I thought of adding a smiley to the post but didn’t. Weak joke begets even weaker joke I’m afraid.

LOL

It’s all good.

Overeem takes this

Better stand up striking. In the clinch JDS will eat nothing but knees, so there goes TD attempts. This will be a stand up fight in which Overeem will be able to control the pace. And the kicks…. JDS is way to focused on being a straight up boxer.

Overeem will get the KO in rd 3.

If it get's to round 3 the only person who will have enough energy to get a KO is JDS

I need to find some comparison pics but I think JDS has more of natural frame for heavyweight and isn’t carrying as much hors…ahem..muscle.

JDS is a better striker than Overeem. JDS has a good chin and solid cardio, Overeem has a suspect chin and below average cardio.

JDS has only 15 pro fights, who has had a chance to test his chin? Roy Nelson?

Last time I checked Roy Nelson hits pretty hard.

Tell that to Andrei Arlovski, :P

If shane carwin swings at you and misses, you chin just got tested.

really?

He’s been hit in the face by:
-CroCop (before he fell off the face of the planet),
-Shane Carwin, who had finished all but one of his previous fights by first round KO (and was a minor officiating decision away from finishing ALL of his previous fights by first round KO).
-Cain Velasquez, who has finished 8 of is 9 fights by KO and was UFC champ, AND
- Roy Nelson, who despite his belly has 9 KO wins in 16 fights.

That would be impressive if it weren't for heavyweights. Your talking about an old CroCop who has dropped 3 in a row, a Shane Carwin whos biggest wins are Gonzaga and Mir and has lost two in a row, and the Roy Nelson who got outstruck by Frank Mir.
If you are going to discredit all of Juniors wins

Then you can easily do the same for Overeem, who is a huge can crusher.

Even if you were right about their overall talent (which you aren't)

It doesn’t make them hit any less hard. The four guys I mentioned account for close to 40 HW knockouts, and they all hit JDS without significantly damaging him. To say his chin hasn’t been tested is ridiculous. JDS has certainly been hit by better HWs wearing 4oz gloves than Overeem has, and it isn’t even close.

When did Cain land any significant strikes to JDS chin?

because I’m not remembering that, at all.

Fightmetric says Cain landed 7-of-14 significant strikes in their fight

which lasted only a little over a minute. I’m assuming some of those are leg kicks, but I am pretty sure he touched JDS’s chin at least once. Either way, its a nitpicky and pointless thing to argue about. The other three guys I mentioned all landed cleanly several times. If Junior’s chin hasn’t been tested, nobody’s has.

Wasn’t trying to nitpick, sorry. I appreciate your input on this site, you seem like one of the more well-informed posters. I just felt like Cain wasn’t a good example of someone who tested JDS chin.

It's all good - and its a fair argument about Cain

I just think a lot of the recurring questions about JDS like cardio, chin and TDD are not the big mysteries that people make them out to be.

shucked

Off those carwin td’s like it was nothing….

Junior ate

ROY’S OVERHAND RIGHT! And stayed awake. Point proven. Jds gots chin.
MegaReem stayed awake through fights with hari,bojansky,aerts, sponge,saki, texteria, and more. Chin? Like a chinese phone book my friend.

the longer the fight goes on, the more kicks JDS will be eating which will kill his cardio. I think thatll happen by RD 3. I think Overeem isnt going to be rushing anything in their fight. He’s going to pick his shots and kicks and they’ll pretty much all be power shots. Every picked shhot is gonna drain JDS, even if he blocks them. Thats what Overeem basically has going as his biggest advantage, the strength.

What you just said applies to both. You think Overeem’s strength will remain the same through out the fight? JDS has better cardio, they’ll both be taking shots. I can’t see too many scenarios where JDS gasses first.

reply fail, meant for Mr Arguello above

throughout the fight, no. Thats why I say Rd 3. If it goes further, JDS could get the better of Overeem. And like I said, Overeem isnt going to be bull rushing or over exerting himself. I think he needs to pick his shots carefully to wear JDS down.

scenario where JDS losses steam: Overeem landing solid body kicks and knees

Honestly, I like JDS' style more

He’s faster with his hands and fights at a higher volume, with tremendous power. Reem is slower and less busy, more menacing and deadly powerful, with his hands, shins and knees. Either one of the guys could come out, land one strike, and go home with a knock out win. Who knows, I’ll take the dog.

Overeem via double underhooks

This will be like the Buentello fight.

JDS couldn't finish Carwin and Nelson

both of whom have iron chins. I can’t find a gif of him dropping Nelson, but I can’t see Overeem taking these hits.

JDS also took a good hook from Carwin to the chin, so he can take a hit (at least as far as he has allowed it).

You must Login with your SB Nation account and be a member of Bloody Elbow to post a comment.